LAST MODIFIED:
In a much earlier tutorial (November, 1999) on my old site I discussed Active Receiving Antennas at some length. I commenced by saying "An active antenna is sometimes used for receiving purposes in instances where a normal antenna would be impossible to accommodate in a physical sense. Such an antenna is sometimes called an aperiodic antenna, other people refer to it as an antenna booster".
In practice, I discussed some of the difficulties in using Active Receiving Antennas, these
were:
1. Compromise of Receiver Dynamic Range:
Dynamic range might generally be described as the ratio of the level of strong out-of-band signals
to the level of the weakest acceptable desired signal.
2. Cross Modulation Distortion:
This occurs when the modulation (e.g. music) of an unwanted strong signal is transferred to a
wanted weak signal (e.g. voice).
3. Inter modulation Distortion: (IMD)
Receivers with many active devices, especially a receiver which has as the first active device an
active receiving antenna, will frequently react in ways that do not always agree with theory.
Well in that earlier tutorial back in November, 1999 I invited my old friend Dr. L.B. Cebik, a professional, world renowned antenna engineer, to review what I had written.
LB said in part "Pre filtering for the bands or band segments of interest can reduce spurious responses from strong out-of-filter signals".
I think there is now sufficient interest in this topic to pursue this aspect further. That is: "pre and post filtering".
ADDED I was deeply saddened to learn my great friend, Leroy Bruce Cebik, W4RNL (SK) who transcended this world from natural causes on or about the early morning hours of April 18, 2008. Here is a fitting tribute from a close friend and colleague.
Before proceeding further I must mention I am greatly indebted to a great many people who have gone before me.
In particular I must mention the extensive work done by R.W. (Bob) Burhans, from whom I learnt a great deal in this area. To my ever-lasting regret I have neither met nor corresponded with Bob, I am totally unable to contact him. Bob, at one time lived in Athens, Ohio, U.SA. I fear the worst...
Serious students of this topic should in particular seek out Bob's series of articles on active receiving antennas which appeared in the now defunct Radio-Electronics Magazine throughout the first half of 1983.
Let's take a look at a rough schematic of a typical active receiving antenna without any
embellishment:
Figure 1 - typical active receiving antenna
What we have here is a small antenna, typically one metre long and perhaps representing a capacitor of around 20 pF, feeding the high impedance input of a source follower amplifier. The amplifier also has an input capacitance, say 7 pF for J310 type J-Fets. The source follower has a low output impedance suitable for connecting to a coaxial cable.
Let's consider why we use only a nominal one metre long antenna. I'm told Bob once wrote an article using a 50 mm (2") antenna, I never saw it (that's a hint to any reader who has) but I can well imagine the justification.
The reason is quite simple, at ANY point in space Signal "X" will have a certain field strength, similarly noise (the enemy) will also have a certain field strength.
Increasing the antenna length will certainly increase the available signal to our input. Unfortunately the available noise increases by the same magnitude, the ratio between the two at your point in space is fixed.
What we are after is an amplifier which has a sufficiently low noise figure that it will amplify the signal without introducing significant additional noise. It will have a sufficiently high input impedance that it does not represent a dead short to the antenna (as the 50 ohm input of a receiver probably would). The output impedance should be similarly low as to comfortably drive a coaxial cable with a receiver attached.
Basicly we're looking at an "impedance converter". What in reality we are looking at is a buffer amplifier.
I strongly suggest you print out both tutorials, impedance and buffer amplifiers, it will probably make life somewhat easier from here onwards.
It is quite critical to your understanding of this topic that you realise a physically short antenna (in terms of wavelength) sees the receiver input terminals as virtually a dead short, especially at lower frequencies where such an antenna may represent only a tiny fraction of a wavelength.
By absorption of the antenna capacitance and the fet input capacitance into certain networks we can achieve a great number of goals. We can absorb these reactances into a low pass filter for example.
For the most part, I will be referring to the fixed frequency 5 Mhz (or 5000 Khz) as may be used in my pet project "Radio VNG 5 Mhz Receiver". All you need do is follow the principles to convert to any band of interest.
Now for a single frequency or, even a particular band or sub-band what can I do?
(a) I could employ a narrow band filter centred at 5 Mhz.
(b) I could employ a low pass filter just above 5 Mhz.
(c) I could employ a high pass filter just below 5 Mhz.
In figure 2 below we will examine the prospect of a narrow band filter centred at 5 Mhz.
Figure 2 - active receiving antenna narrow band filter
If you followed the tutorial on narrow band filters it should be fairly easy.
Dick Rollema, PAØSE has "Another Approach to Active Antennas" page where he says in part:
"As a result the E-field probe, a piece of copper tube of 50cm long and 3cm diameter, now feeds a current into the FET at the input. Because of the probe's capacitive impedance the current increases with frequency at 6dB/octave. This is compensated by negative feedback. Nordholt calls it an 'integrating transimpedance amplifier in order to obtain a frequency independent transfer of the antenna signal'."
Read Dick's story here.
My friend Chris Trask has a list of interesting Active Antenna References for the purists - these are not links.
Our friends at Amazon, with whom I am affiliated, apparently now stock Ramsey Electronics Kits including the relatively low cost Ramsey AA7C Active Antenna Kit. Definitely worth a look.
Product Description
"Our AA7C features both a high gain, low noise FET and a superb microwave bipolar amplifier, letting you use the antenna on all bands - shortwave, HF, VHF and UHF! Imagine a self-contained unit just 4 inches square that pulls in the signals like a 60 foot long wire; that's the advantage of an active antenna. For jazzing up VHF/UHF receivers and scanners, the AA7C has you covered, too".
Ramsey AA7C Active Antenna Kit.
antenna basics
narrow band filters
earth dangers
impedance
mobius winding techniques
radio telescopes
I would also suggest that you take a good look at L.B. Cebik 's W4RNL great web site. My good friend LB is "THE antenna guru"
NEW! - How to link directly to this page
Want to create a page link to me from your site? It couldn't be easier. No HTML knowledge required; even the technophobes can do it. All you need to do is copy and paste, the following code. All links are greatly appreciated; I sincerely thank you for your support.
Copy and paste the following code for a text link:
<a
href="https://www.electronics-tutorials.com/antennas/active-receiving-antennas.htm"
target="_top">visit Ian Purdie VK2TIP's "Active Receiving Antennas"
Page</a>
and it should appear like this:
visit Ian Purdie VK2TIP's "Active Receiving Antennas" Page
the author Ian C. Purdie, VK2TIP of www.electronics-tutorials.com
asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this web site and all contents herein.
Copyright © 2000, all rights reserved. See copying and links. These
electronic tutorials are provided for individual private use and the author assumes no liability
whatsoever for the application, use, misuse, of any of these projects or electronics tutorials that
may result in the direct or indirect damage or loss that comes from these projects or tutorials.
All materials are provided for free private and public use.
Commercial use prohibited without prior written permission from
www.electronics-tutorials.com.
Copyright © 2000 - 2001, all rights reserved. URL - https://www.electronics-tutorials.com/antennas/active-receiving-antennas.htm
Updated 21st April, 2002
